How to Choose Between Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye

If you're planning a trip to Belize and considering the islands, two names will come up again and again: Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye. While both offer access to the Belize Barrier Reef and beautiful Caribbean scenery, the experience on each island is different. This guide breaks down the key differences to help you decide which destination fits your travel style.

Caye Caulker vs Ambergris Caye: At a Glance

Atmosphere

• Caye Caulker: Laid-back, small village feel

• Ambergris Caye: Livelier, more developed

Transportation

• Caye Caulker: No cars, walkable and bike-friendly

• Ambergris Caye: Golf carts, some cars, larger area

Snorkeling Access

• Caye Caulker: Very close to reef, easy tour access

• Ambergris Caye: Also excellent, more operators

Nightlife

• Caye Caulker: Low-key beach bars

• Ambergris Caye: More options, bars and clubs

Cost

• Caye Caulker: Budget to mid-range

• Ambergris Caye: Mid-range to expensive

Ideal For

• Caye Caulker: Relaxation, solo travelers, couples

• Ambergris Caye: Travelers seeking more tourist-centric activities

Snorkeling and Diving Access

Both islands offer outstanding access to the Belize Barrier Reef, but Caye Caulker's proximity means many tours leave right from the village. Snorkeling destinations like Hol Chan Marine Reserve and Shark Ray Alley are easily reached within 20 to 30 minutes.

Ambergris Caye also has excellent reef access, with more tour operators offering a range of trips. Because of its size, you may need to travel a bit more from your resort or accommodation to reach tour docks.

Transportation and Size

Caye Caulker is small and walkable. There are no cars on the island, only bicycles and a few golf carts. You can get from one end of the island to the other in about 20 minutes.

Ambergris Caye is much larger, and transportation is built around golf carts and some small vehicles. While this offers more flexibility, it also means you'll spend more time navigating the island, especially during busy seasons.

Cost and Accommodations

Caye Caulker tends to attract travelers on a budget or those seeking a boutique stay. Lodging ranges from hostels to mid-tier beachfront villas. Food and activities are generally more affordable.

Ambergris Caye has a wider range of accommodations, including large resorts and high-end condos. Prices reflect the more developed nature of the island, especially near San Pedro.

Nightlife and Entertainment

If nightlife is part of your vacation, Ambergris Caye has more to offer. San Pedro has bars, clubs, and live music several nights a week. There’s more foot traffic in the evenings and more late-night food options.

Caye Caulker has a quieter nightlife scene. The Split is a popular place to watch the sunset and enjoy a drink, and a few local bars offer music and conversation, but the overall vibe is slower and quieter after dark.

Choose Caye Caulker if:

• You prefer slower, less commercial destinations

• You want to walk or bike everywhere

• You’re planning a romantic getaway, solo trip, or eco-focused vacation

• You’re looking for budget-friendly options without sacrificing reef access

Choose Ambergris Caye if:

• You want more amenities and tour options

• You enjoy nightlife, shopping, and a faster pace

• You want resort-style lodging with more on-site services

• You're interested in a wider variety of dining and excursion options

Can You Visit Both?

Yes. The two islands are only about 30 minutes apart by water taxi. Many travelers choose to stay on one and day trip to the other. Ashton Court Belize can help you coordinate inter-island travel and excursions to make the most of your time.

Let Ashton Court Belize Help You Decide

Whether you're leaning toward Caye Caulker's relaxed pace or want to explore both islands, Ashton Court Belize can help you build the perfect itinerary. Our concierge team offers personalized recommendations, tour bookings, and travel support so you can explore Belize with confidence.

Explore our concierge services to start planning your Belize island experience.