10 Best Restaurants on Caye Caulker, Belize - Where to Eat on the Island

Caye Caulker isn’t just a paradise for sun-seekers and adventure lovers, it’s a foodie’s dream getaway. The island is full of vibrant restaurants, from tucked away local gems to breezy seaside spots with fresh seafood and bold Caribbean flavors.

Whether you're here for a quick getaway or planning a destination wedding, retreat, or private dinner, Ashton Court Belize offers a boutique stay with personalized day planning and expert event hosting. While you explore these must-try restaurants, let Ashton Court handle all the little details, like tailored island excursions and private dinners with menus curated by top local chefs.

2. Pasta Per Caso Anna & Armando 

This tiny Italian gem is run with heart. Fresh pasta, seasonal ingredients, and warm service make every bite memorable. The rotating menu keeps things interesting, and the cozy ambiance invites you to linger.

Recreate the experience at Ashton Court Belize with a private Italian-themed dinner, handcrafted just for you.

3. Pelican Sunset Bar 

For unbeatable sunset views and a laid-back vibe, Pelican Sunset Bar is the spot. Sip something fruity while enjoying grilled seafood with the ocean as your backdrop.

Picture a rooftop cocktail hour at sunset on the island with handcrafted drinks and ocean-fresh tapas all timed to the golden hour.

4. Dee N’ D’s 

This local treasure is all about flavor, fire, and beachfront vibes. At Dee N’ D’s, you’ll find grilled lobster pulled straight from the sea, shrimp skewers kissed by flame, and smoky Belizean barbecue that’s bursting with island spices.

The setting is simple: picnic tables under the palms, with the breeze rolling in and the scent of sizzling seafood filling the air. It’s casual, it’s authentic, and it’s the kind of spot where you’ll want to linger long after your plate is clean.

5. Errolyn’s House of Fry Jacks 

Start your morning like a local with Errolyn’s legendary fry jacks; puffy, golden, and filled with cheese, beans, or eggs. It’s a must while you’re on the island.

Want breakfast in your robe? Stay at Ashton Court Belize and enjoy fry jacks and tropical smoothies delivered right to your private veranda.

6. Ice and Beans Café 

Known for strong coffee, smoothies, and famous mini donuts, Ice and Beans is a chill place (pun intended) to start your day or refuel after a bike ride.

You don’t have to leave your villa for good coffee because you can sip on your balcony at Ashton Court Belize while the Caribbean shoreline sparkles in front of you.

7. Roy’s Blue Water Grill 

This no-fuss favorite serves grilled fish, lobster, and bold dishes like coconut chicken curry and jerk shrimp. Colorful and casual, Roy’s is great for a relaxed lunch or early dinner.

8. Chef Juan’s Kitchen and Pastries 

From filling Caribbean dishes to flaky pastries, Chef Juan’s is your go-to for comfort food and casual dining. Portions are generous and flavors are rich.

9. Hibisca Restaurant 

Hibisca is part dinner spot, part island party. With Caribbean dishes, live music, and colorful decor, it’s the kind of place that turns dinner into a memory.

Planning a group celebration? Ashton Court Belize can host a festive dinner with a live music vibe and flavors inspired by Hibisca.

10. Maggie’s Sunset Kitchen 

Maggie’s is a peaceful hideaway with stunning sunset views and some of the best spicy shrimp and curry seafood bowls on the island. It’s low-key, relaxing, and full of flavor.

Let Ashton Court Belize organize a private sunset dinner inspired by Maggie’s, complete with ocean breeze, local flavors, and total privacy.

Make Ashton Court Belize Your Home Base

With this many amazing restaurants to try, you’ll want a place to recharge, relax, and feel totally taken care of. That’s where Ashton Court Belize shines.

✔️ Boutique accommodations just steps from Caye Caulker’s top dining spots
✔️ Personalized adventure and day planning to help you explore it all
✔️ Private event hosting and catering for weddings, retreats, and special moments

Let us handle the details so you can focus on the fun, the flavors, and the unforgettable moments.

Reserve Your Stay and start planning your dream island getaway today!